7 Comments
User's avatar
Gabriel Franco's avatar

First of all, I'd like to say that this article is very well written and that I enjoyed it very much. I agree with you in that the fatal flaw of these theories is the belief of a utopia on earth. After all, what business does an imperfect being have in finding a perfect society? Although I'm not religious or believe in a deity, I find it entirely reasonable that religion shouldn't have a model for how society should work. In a sense, it is definitely above politics. It sets its sights on something a lot less tangible than just the world we live on. Therefore, I believe church shouldn't necessarily dictate how a society should work, but it should give an idea on how to find meaning in it all.

Expand full comment
Kelly Garrison's avatar

Thank you so much for reading, and welcome!

Expand full comment
Brian Shepherd's avatar

I enjoyed this article very much. Very well organized, analyzed, and presented. I’ve started atlas shrugged a few times but never finished. Part of it is I have not spent much time on understanding Ayn Rand. Now i feel better equipped to read the book with the background and context presented here.

Expand full comment
Kelly Garrison's avatar

Thank you so much, I really appreciate your comment! I never read it after finishing Atlas Shrugged, but I’ve been told The Fountainhead is better.

Expand full comment
Emma Donovan's avatar

This article hit on something I've been considering: how to reach for an ideal (ie, a heavenly one of a holy and virtuous life) without becoming a utopian.

Expand full comment
Kelly Garrison's avatar

You and me both!! Thank you so much for reading!

Expand full comment
Robert C Culwell's avatar

A = A ⚖️

But Ayn Rand is a tough nut to crack and an impossible circle to square! 🇺🇲

Resist the COLLECTIVE! 🗽🔔📜💪🏼🌐

Individual Liberty and Personal Responsibility ✔️

Private property, both physically and intellectually sovereign.....

She goes pretty light on loving one's neighbor in practice and shuns the Mystery of Faith while seeking real beauty and courage. (marxism w/o faith🤔)

I will have to go back through the post! Thank you sister.

Expand full comment